← Back to “The Aim Was Song” by Robert Frost
“The Aim Was Song” by Robert Frost — Literary Analysis
Overview
In four tight quatrains from New Hampshire (1923), Robert Frost retells the origin of song. Wind blows raw and untaught, loud in any rough place where it catches; then a human takes a little of it into the mouth, holds it long enough for north to turn into south, and gives it back by measure. The poem is a miniature ars poetica, a parable about how nature becomes art.
The trick of the poem is that man does not silence the wind or replace it. He borrows breath, reshapes it, and returns it as word and note. Frost is careful with his pronouns in the last stanza: the song is "the wind the wind had meant to be." That odd doubling personifies the wind and grants it a purpose it did not know it had, so the closing line — "the wind could see" — reads less as conquest than as recognition. The wind, in some sense, agrees.
Readers who know Frost's earlier "Mowing" will hear a familiar insistence. There, the scythe whispers because "anything more than the truth would have seemed too weak." Here, the wind needs a human throat to become articulate, and only the human touch — measured, small — turns weather into music. Sound precedes meaning, and the work of the poet, as the work of the mower, is to make sense out of what the world is already trying to say.
Key Themes
- Nature and art
- Ars poetica
- Measure and restraint
- The human voice as instrument
- Intention and recognition
Notable Craft Elements
- Four ABAB quatrains of iambic tetrameter — the shortest possible frame for the argument
- The verb "measure" becomes the hinge of the poem, naming both metrical form and moral restraint
- The doubled "the wind the wind" in the final stanza performs the very conversion the poem describes
- Personification strengthens across stanzas until the wind itself can "see" what has happened
Reread Prompt
If the wind already "meant" to be song, does the poem celebrate human art, or does it credit nature with an intention the poet merely completes?
Historical Context
Frost first published "The Aim Was Song" in the inaugural issue of The Measure: A Journal of Poetry in March 1921, then collected it in New Hampshire (New York: Henry Holt, 1923), illustrated with woodcuts by his friend J. J. Lankes. That volume — whose full title, New Hampshire: A Poem with Notes and Grace Notes, announces its own compositional self-consciousness — won the 1924 Pulitzer Prize for Poetry, the first of four Frost would receive. It also gathered many of his most anthologized lyrics, including "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening," "Fire and Ice," "Nothing Gold Can Stay," and "Dust of Snow."
By 1923 Frost was no longer the obscure poet who had published A Boy's Will in London a decade earlier. He was forty-nine, newly famous, and increasingly interested in how a poem announces its own method. "The Aim Was Song" belongs to a small cluster of lyrics in New Hampshire that carry the book's ars-poetica weight without straining for grandeur. It is short, argumentative, and technically plainspoken — a poet in mid-career describing, through a fable about wind, what he thinks a poem does.
Formal Analysis
The poem is sixteen lines in four ABAB quatrains. The meter is iambic tetrameter (four beats per line, eight syllables under most countings), not the pentameter that some online summaries claim. Line one scans cleanly: "Be-FORE / man CAME / to BLOW / it RIGHT." Line nine is equally strict: "He TOOK / a LIT- / tle IN / his MOUTH." The choice matters. Frost keeps an unrelieved 4-4-4-4 pattern rather than the common-meter 4-3-4-3 of hymn and ballad, so the effect is closer to nursery rhyme or the light-verse side of Longfellow than to meditative English pentameter. The line sits lower than the ten-syllable line of deep thought, and higher than doggerel. It is song-shaped.
Each stanza performs a structural move. The first describes the wind's untaught state. The second introduces man as a corrective voice. The third describes the physical act of conversion. The fourth names the result and repeats "by measure" as a sentence of its own: "By measure." That stranded phrase, its period early, is the poem's most formally violent gesture — a small act of prosodic measurement that draws attention to the concept by demonstrating it. The word "measure" repeats three times across the short poem. The phrase "the aim was song" appears twice, bracketing the argument. Together they build the refrain of a song about songmaking.
Thematic Analysis
The central argument looks tidy: nature supplies the raw material, humans supply the shaping, and the result is art. The last stanza makes that tidy account more interesting. "The wind the wind had meant to be" is a grammatically odd construction that reads best as apposition — the measured song is the wind as the wind intended itself. Read that way, the wind is not conquered but clarified. It had an aim all along; the human mouth was needed to realize it.
This is a more interesting claim than anthropocentric mastery. If the wind "meant" to be song, then art is not an imposition on nature but a completion of what nature was attempting. The poet is something like a midwife — essential to the birth, but not the originator. The final clause, "the wind could see," closes the parable with an image of reciprocal recognition. The wind, now personified with both intention and sight, acknowledges its own form in the human song. This is not triumphalism; it is mutual arrival.
The poem also insists, quietly, on restraint. Three times Frost uses the word "measure" or its cognates. The human takes only "a little" of the wind, the conversion happens "by measure," and what emerges is song rather than shout. Frost is arguing against the very quality the untaught wind displays in stanza one — blowing "its loudest day and night / In any rough place where it caught." Art, for Frost, is the opposite of being loudest everywhere. It is the discipline of choosing a small amount and holding it long enough for something to change.
Language & Imagery
The core image is a chain: wind → breath → measured song. Frost moves the wind through the human body — "a little in his mouth," held "long enough for north / To be converted into south," then "by measure blew it forth" — so that the transformation is physiological, not metaphysical. Art happens in the lips and throat. The north-to-south conversion is the poem's one surprising image; it names the interior warming that turns cold outside air into voiced sound, and it quietly makes the mouth a compass.
"By measure" carries two senses at once. It means in a regulated, small amount (as one takes medicine by measure) and in poetic meter. Both meanings are active, and Frost will not choose between them. The poem's refrain, "the aim was song," also holds a double valence — aim as goal and aim as the direction of a blown breath. The wind has a goal and a trajectory; so does the poet. Where they meet is the poem.
Intertextual Connections
"The Aim Was Song" belongs to a Frost lineage of quiet ars poetica lyrics, most notably "Mowing" from A Boy's Will, in which the whispering scythe teaches that "the fact is the sweetest dream that labor knows." Both poems route poetic making through a body at work — a scythe, a mouth — and both distrust grand claims about inspiration. The connection to Frost's prose is also audible. In letters to John Bartlett in 1913-1914, Frost formulated what he called "the sound of sense" — the music of spoken English as the ground of verse. "The Aim Was Song" is that doctrine in parable form: meaning begins as sound, and the poet's job is to shape the sound until it carries the sense. Hear it in line eight, where the poem breaks into plain spoken address: "And listen—how it ought to go!" The imperative "listen" does the work the whole essay will later argue for. Frost would return to this idea, more discursively, in the 1939 preface "The Figure a Poem Makes."
Discussion Prompts
- The final line says "the wind could see." What does it mean for a wind to see, and does the poem earn the personification?
- Frost uses the word "measure" three times and builds the poem around it. List every occurrence and describe how each shifts the meaning of the word.
- Compare the wind in "The Aim Was Song" with the scythe in Frost's "Mowing." How does each poem locate the source of song?
- Is "The Aim Was Song" a poem about human mastery over nature, or about nature completing itself through human speech? Defend your reading with specific lines.
- The poem is written in iambic tetrameter (eight syllables per line). Try rewriting one stanza in iambic pentameter (ten syllables per line). How does the feel of the argument change, and why might Frost have chosen the shorter line?
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is "The Aim Was Song" about?
- The poem tells a small fable about how song begins. Wind blows raw and untaught until a person takes a little of it into the mouth, holds it long enough for the cold air to warm, and releases it "by measure." The result is word and note — song. Frost is describing the making of poetry through the image of breath: nature supplies the material, the human body shapes it, and what emerges is the wind "the wind had meant to be." The poem is a miniature ars poetica.
- Is "The Aim Was Song" an ars poetica?
- Yes. An ars poetica is a poem about the making of poems, and "The Aim Was Song" is one of the cleanest examples in Frost's work. Every element of the fable doubles as a claim about poetry: the wind is raw sound, the mouth is the poet's ear and instrument, "measure" is poetic meter, and the finished "word and note" is the poem itself. Frost would restate the same idea, more discursively, in his 1939 essay "The Figure a Poem Makes."
- What is the meter of "The Aim Was Song"?
- Iambic tetrameter — four beats per line, eight syllables. Some online summaries incorrectly call it pentameter. A quick scansion confirms the tetrameter: "Be-FORE / man CAME / to BLOW / it RIGHT" or "He TOOK / a LIT- / tle IN / his MOUTH." Frost keeps an unrelieved 4-4-4-4 pattern rather than the 4-3-4-3 of hymn common meter, placing the poem closer to nursery rhyme or Longfellow's lighter quatrains than to the pentameter of meditative verse.
- When and where was "The Aim Was Song" first published?
- "The Aim Was Song" first appeared in the inaugural issue of The Measure: A Journal of Poetry, vol. 1, no. 1, in March 1921. It was then collected in Frost's book New Hampshire (New York: Henry Holt, 1923), which won the 1924 Pulitzer Prize for Poetry — the first of four Pulitzers Frost would receive. The volume was illustrated with woodcuts by his friend J. J. Lankes.
- What does "by measure" mean in the poem?
- "By measure" carries two senses at once. The first is practical: in a regulated, small amount — the way one takes medicine by measure. The second is prosodic: in poetic meter. Frost does not choose between the meanings; both are active. Art, for him, is what emerges when a human takes only a little of the natural material and returns it under formal discipline. The stranded sentence "By measure." in the final stanza enacts the concept it names.
- How does the poem relate to Frost's "sound of sense" theory?
- In letters to John Bartlett in 1913-1914, Frost argued that poetry's deepest music is the cadence of spoken English — what he called "the sound of sense." "The Aim Was Song" dramatizes the doctrine. Meaning begins as untamed sound (the wind), and the poet's job is to shape the sound until it carries the sense. Line eight breaks into spoken address: "And listen—how it ought to go!" The imperative "listen" compresses the whole theory into a syllable.
- Is the poem celebrating human mastery over nature?
- Not straightforwardly. The final stanza calls the song "the wind the wind had meant to be" — as if the wind had intended song all along and needed the human mouth only to realize that intention. The closing line, "the wind could see," reads less as conquest than as recognition, with both parties arriving at a shared form. The poem is closer to a parable of completion than of mastery. The human does not silence or replace the wind; he returns it, shaped, to itself.
Sources
- Robert Frost. New Hampshire: A Poem with Notes and Grace Notes. Henry Holt and Company, 1923.
- Robert Frost (contributor). The Measure: A Journal of Poetry, vol. 1, no. 1, 1921.
- Robert Frost. The Figure a Poem Makes. Henry Holt and Company, 1939.
- Robert Frost. Letters to John Bartlett, 1913-1914, 1913.
- 1924 Pulitzer Prize for Poetry citation, 1924.
See something wrong on this page? Let us know.